What Does “Revise and Resubmit” Mean?
“Revise and resubmit” — usually shortened to R&R — is an editorial decision: the journal will not accept the manuscript in its current form, but it is willing to consider a new version after substantial changes. It is an opportunity, not a promise of acceptance, and how you plan and document the revision largely decides what happens next.
A revise-and-resubmit decision means the editor sees enough potential to invite another version, but the current manuscript is not ready for acceptance. The next decision depends on how well the revision addresses the editor and reviewer concerns. Treat the decision letter as a new project plan: identify required scientific changes, decide whether the requested work is feasible, revise the manuscript thoroughly, and submit a transparent point-by-point response.
What Revise and Resubmit Means
An R&R sits between acceptance and rejection. The editor and reviewers see a contribution worth pursuing, but they have concerns that must be resolved before the paper can be accepted — about the methods, the analysis, how the findings are framed, missing literature, or simply clarity.
Journals word this decision differently. Some call it a major revision, others “revise and resubmit”, and some use “reject and resubmit” or “reject with encouragement to resubmit”. The label matters less than the letter itself: the editor's comments, not the decision name, tell you how much work is expected and how the revised version will be handled.
R&R vs Major Revision vs Reject and Resubmit
Major revision: the manuscript usually stays in the same submission, and the revised version goes back to the editor and, often, the original reviewers together with your response letter.
Revise and resubmit: often used as a synonym for major revision. At some journals, though, the revised paper receives a new manuscript number and is treated more like a fresh submission, which can mean new reviewers.
Reject and resubmit: the current submission is closed, but the editor is open to a substantially reworked version. Expect it to be evaluated largely as a new paper.
Minor revision: limited, well-defined changes, frequently checked by the editor alone. If you are unsure which category your decision falls into, the submission system's status and the editor's wording are the most reliable guide — and you can ask the editorial office.
R&R Is Not Acceptance
The manuscript remains under evaluation. Reviewers will check whether each of their concerns was addressed, and the editor will weigh the revision as a whole. A thorough, well-documented revision can resolve the main obstacles; an incomplete or defensive one can lead to another revision round or to rejection.
Treat the decision as a new project with a deadline rather than a formality. The authors who do best after an R&R are usually the ones who take every comment seriously, including the small ones.
Read the Editor's Letter Before the Reviews
The editor's summary often reveals which reviewer concerns are decision-critical and which are secondary. Look for wording such as “essential”, “must be addressed” or “in particular”, and note any point where the editor agrees with one reviewer over another or tells you a request is optional.
Also record the practical requirements in the letter: the deadline, any word or figure limits, formatting changes, and what the journal expects you to upload with the revision.
Decide Whether the Revision Is Feasible
Sort every request into a few groups: new data or experiments, new or different analyses, restructuring or reframing, and clarifications or presentation changes. Estimate the time each group needs before you commit to a resubmission date.
Some requests cannot reasonably be met — the data no longer exist, ethical approval does not cover the new work, or the experiment is outside the study's scope. In those cases, plan to explain why and offer what you can instead, such as a sensitivity analysis, a clearer limitation, or a narrower claim. If the total work would change the core of the paper, or the journal no longer fits, withdrawing and submitting elsewhere is a legitimate decision.
How Long Do You Have to Resubmit?
The deadline is set by the journal and is stated in the decision letter or the submission system; it varies by journal and by how much work is requested. Put it in your plan on day one.
If the requested work genuinely needs more time, write to the editor before the deadline, explain what is taking longer, and propose a realistic date. Many journals accommodate reasonable requests, but missing the deadline without contact may mean the revision is treated as a new submission.
Plan the Revision as a Traceable Workflow
Number every comment and build a revision matrix: comment number, reviewer, what is requested, your decision (address fully, partially, or decline with a reason), the action taken, the manuscript location (page and line), who is responsible, and status. This becomes the control document for the revision and the backbone of your response letter.
Group comments that several reviewers raised, deal with the editor's priorities first, and keep a version of the manuscript with changes marked so you can point reviewers to exactly what changed.
What to Submit With the Revised Manuscript
Requirements vary, so check the journal's instructions, but a resubmission package usually includes: the revised manuscript; a version with changes tracked or highlighted, if the journal asks for one; a point-by-point response to the reviewers; a short cover letter to the editor summarizing the main changes; and any updated figures, tables, supplementary files or declarations.
Make sure numbers, figure labels and page references are consistent across the manuscript and the response letter — reviewers notice when they are not.
Writing the Response to Reviewers
Respond to every comment, in order. Quote or paraphrase the comment, state what you changed, and say where the change appears. Thank reviewers where it is genuine, but keep the focus on substance.
You can disagree with a reviewer, but do it with evidence and a calm tone, and show that you considered the point — for example by adding a clarification or a limitation even when you do not make the requested change. The related guides below cover point-by-point responses, examples, and how to disagree respectfully in more detail.
When to Contact the Editor
Contact the editor when requested changes conflict with each other, when the deadline is unrealistic for the work requested, or when a requested experiment or dataset cannot reasonably be produced. A short, specific message before you invest weeks of work is better than an explanation after the fact.
Common Mistakes After an R&R
Skipping “minor” comments; changing the manuscript without saying where; arguing with a reviewer without evidence; making large unrequested changes without flagging them; leaving inconsistencies between the manuscript and the response letter; and letting the deadline pass without contacting the journal. Each of these can turn a promising R&R into another round of review or a rejection.
Frequently asked questions
No. It means the journal is willing to evaluate a substantially revised version. Acceptance depends on how well the revision addresses the editor's and reviewers' concerns.
Generally, yes: the editor sees enough potential to invite another version instead of rejecting the paper. It still requires substantial, careful work, and the outcome is not guaranteed.
Many journals use the terms interchangeably. Where they differ, an R&R is more likely to be handled as a new submission with a new manuscript number, possibly with new reviewers, while a major revision usually stays in the original submission.
Often the original reviewers are invited again, but the editor may add new reviewers or assess the revision alone. Write your response so that someone who did not read the first version can still follow it.
Not necessarily. Consider the scope of the requested work, journal fit, timing, and whether the editor's requirements are feasible. If you decide to go elsewhere, formally withdraw first — never submit the paper to two journals at once.
Often yes. If the requested work genuinely requires more time, contact the editor before the deadline, explain why, and propose a realistic new date.
No, but you must respond to every comment. Where you do not make a change, explain why with evidence or reasoning, and consider a smaller change — such as a clarification or limitation — that addresses the underlying concern.
References
- PMC — A Practical Guide on Responding to Reviews
Peer-reviewed practical guidance on preparing revisions and point-by-point responses.
- ICMJE Recommendations
International recommendations on responsible manuscript preparation, reporting, and editorial practice.
